I received the following IM from a friend today:
What is your all time nba team? Mine is kobe bryant at point; michael jordan as 2; tracy mcrady at 3; hakeem olajuwon at 4; shaq oneal as center.
I don’t even think it is necessary to comment on the absurdity of this list, but I will anyway.
Um, Larry Bird and Magic Johnson are omitted. Enough said. (But I’ll continue)
Tracy McGrady is a fraud until proven otherwise. Play for a winner and then we’ll talk. Kobe is a great champion, but only as second banana. He needs to win one as the undisputed leader on a team, and then we’ll talk. (He’s also not a point guard, but that is so minor I’ll choose to overlook it)
Essentially, positions 1-3 are locks: Magic, Michael and Larry. It does get interesting once you get to 4 and 5. The most dominant centers of their time are obviously Bill Russell and Wilt Chamberlain, but the game has changed so much since they played; It is extremely hard to compare these guys to modern day greats like Shaq. Perhaps 70’s stars Kareem or Bill Walton are the ultimate compromise — skilled enough to play a finesse game but tough enough to handle today’s centers. The statistical factor comes into play here as well — Karl Malone, for example, is the greatest power forward of all time based on statistics, but if I were putting together a team I’d much rather have Kevin McHale, Hakeem or even Charles Barkley playing the 4.
To answer my friend, I told him that my team of Magic, The Big O, Larry Legend, McHale and Kareem would blow his team off the court. Even though Jordan is the greatest competitor and winner of all time, there is no way he could overcome the selfishness of Kobe and T-Mac to keep his team in the game.